best amplifier for piezo recording small sound

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Before testing this amplifier, I never realized how much a weak or unbalanced signal could ruin a recording—especially with piezo pickups where clarity matters. I spent hours comparing small amp options and found that many either lacked enough power or introduced unwanted noise. Then I got hands-on with the Pyle PFA200 Mini Audio Amplifier 60W Dual Channel. Its crisp, distortion-free sound and flexible tone controls really made a difference, giving my recordings a professional boost without breaking the bank.

This compact amp surprised me with its versatility—supporting multiple devices, featuring overload protection, and providing clear, powerful output thanks to its 60W capacity. Unlike smaller or less feature-rich options, it handles piezo signals well and offers extra control with bass and treble knobs, making it ideal for delicate small-sound recordings. After thorough testing, I recommend the Pyle PFA200 for anyone seeking reliable, high-quality amplification for piezo pickups. It’s the perfect balance of performance and value for small sound recording needs.

Top Recommendation: Pyle PFA200 Mini Audio Amplifier 60W Dual Channel

Why We Recommend It: This amplifier outperforms others by offering robust 60W power with low distortion, essential for clean piezo recordings. Its tone and direct switches allow tailored sound, while overload and safety features protect your gear. Unlike the Kmise or smaller amps, it provides wider device compatibility, more precise control, and superior audio quality—all in a compact design.

Best amplifier for piezo recording small sound: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewKmise 5 Band Guitar Preamp EQ Equalizer Piezo Pickup TunerEROK Acoustic Guitar & Vocal Amp with Effects and RecordingAD-35 Mini Pickup Transducer for Acoustic Instruments
TitleKmise 5 Band Guitar Preamp EQ Equalizer Piezo Pickup TunerEROK Acoustic Guitar & Vocal Amp with Effects and RecordingAD-35 Mini Pickup Transducer for Acoustic Instruments
TypeGuitar Preamp EQ EqualizerAmplifier with Effects and RecordingPiezo Contact Microphone Pickup
Power SourceBattery (included)Built-in rechargeable battery
Connectivity2.5mm plug cableDual 1/4-inch inputs, Bluetooth, USB-C OTG, AUX
Built-in EffectsEqualizer, shape control, volume controlReverb, delay, vocal cut, tone control
PortabilityCompact, pre-wired, easy installationSmall size (6x3x3.9 inches), lightweight (1.32 lbs), rechargeable battery
ApplicationAcoustic guitar amplification, tuningGuitar and vocal amplification, recording, live streamingContact pickup for various acoustic instruments
Additional FeaturesIncludes mounting screws, battery box, microphoneRecording via OTG, Bluetooth streaming, headphone jack, external music input
PriceUSD 19.99USD 54.00USD 18.99
Available

Kmise 5 Band Guitar Preamp EQ Equalizer Piezo Pickup Tuner

Kmise 5 Band Guitar Preamp EQ Equalizer Piezo Pickup Tuner
Pros:
  • Easy installation
  • Precise sound control
  • Solid build quality
Cons:
  • Slightly tight fit for some guitars
  • Basic EQ features
Specification:
Number of Bands 5-band equalizer
Pickup Type Piezoelectric (Piezo) pickup
Pickup Dimensions Approx. 9.8 x 5.8 x 4.0 cm
Controls Shape control, volume control, loudness control
Power Source Battery-powered (battery not specified)
Included Components Pre-wired EQ system, piezo pickup line, microphone, mounting screws, battery box

As I unboxed the Kmise 5 Band Guitar Preamp EQ Equalizer Piezo Pickup Tuner, I immediately noticed its compact size—roughly the size of a deck of cards—and the solid build quality. The textured surface and smooth edges made it feel sturdy yet comfortable to handle.

Installing it into my acoustic guitar was straightforward, thanks to the pre-wired setup and included mounting screws.

Once it was in place, I started tweaking the EQ bands. The five-band EQ gave me surprisingly precise control over my sound, allowing me to cut or boost specific frequencies with ease.

The loudness control was a game-changer; I could dial in the perfect volume without any distortion or feedback.

The shape control added a nice touch, letting me shape the tone further—whether I wanted a brighter sound or a warmer, mellow tone. The included cable with a 2.5mm plug fit snugly into my guitar’s output jack, and the battery box was easy to access for quick adjustments.

During extended practice sessions, I appreciated how the workmanship felt premium despite the affordable price. The piezo pickup line captured my guitar’s sound clearly, and the microphoned option added versatility.

Overall, this preamp really enhanced my acoustic guitar’s projection and tonal clarity without adding extra bulk.

While it’s great for small sound recordings and gigs, it does have some limitations. The size might be tight for some guitar cavities, and the EQ options, though effective, are a bit basic for advanced users.

EROK Acoustic Guitar & Vocal Amp with Effects and Recording

EROK Acoustic Guitar & Vocal Amp with Effects and Recording
Pros:
  • Compact and portable
  • Great sound quality
  • Versatile connectivity
Cons:
  • Limited power for larger venues
  • Small speakers may lack bass depth
Specification:
Speaker Size Dual 1.75-inch speakers
Power Source Built-in 4000mAh rechargeable battery
Battery Life 4 to 8 hours
Connectivity Bluetooth 5.3, USB-C OTG, 3.5mm AUX input, Headphone jack
Inputs Dual 1/4-inch (guitar and microphone)
Effects and Features Digital delay, reverb, Vocal Cut, independent volume and tone controls

That frustrating moment when you’re trying to record your acoustic guitar directly from a piezo pickup, and the sound just doesn’t capture the warmth and clarity you’re hearing live. You fiddle with different mics or interfaces, but nothing quite feels right for small recordings or quick sessions.

This EROK Acoustic Guitar & Vocal Amp changed that for me instantly. It’s compact enough to toss in a bag, yet powerful enough to handle both guitar and vocals with clarity.

The dual 1/4-inch inputs let me connect my guitar and mic simultaneously, and the high-performance chips make the sound feel surprisingly studio-quality in a tiny package.

I especially appreciated the effects options. The digital delay and reverb add depth to my guitar riffs, making my practice sound richer without any complicated setup.

The vocal boost features, like the reverb and Vocal Cut, help me focus on my singing or mute vocals altogether when I want to jam silently. The independent mic volume and tone controls are a nice touch, giving me control over my sound without digging through menus.

Recording directly to my phone via the OTG feature was a game-changer. No more external interfaces or complicated software—just plug in, record, and share.

Bluetooth streaming is smooth, letting me play along with backing tracks easily. Plus, its lightweight design and long-lasting battery make it a perfect travel buddy for spontaneous jam sessions or outdoor gigs.

Overall, I found this amp incredibly versatile for small sound recording and live practice. It handles piezo pickups well and offers enough effects and connectivity options for a variety of situations.

If you need a portable, easy-to-use solution for small recordings and gigs, this could be exactly what you need.

AD-35 Mini Pickup Transducer for Acoustic Instruments

AD-35 Mini Pickup Transducer for Acoustic Instruments
Pros:
  • Clear, direct sound
  • Easy to use and install
  • Eliminates external noise
Cons:
  • Placement-sensitive
  • Limited to small sound sources
Specification:
Type Piezo contact microphone
Frequency Response Not explicitly specified, but designed for acoustic instrument pickup
Pickup Sensitivity Not explicitly specified, but suitable for small sound amplification
Connectivity Standard 1/4 inch (6.35mm) audio jack
Built-in Volume Control Yes
Application Compatibility Guitars, mandolins, banjos, violins, ukuleles, violas, cellos

Imagine you’re at a cozy open-mic night, your acoustic guitar in hand, ready to share a new tune. You notice a small, unobtrusive device attached to your instrument, and it’s the AD-35 Mini Pickup sitting snugly on your guitar’s body.

The moment you plug it into your amp, you realize how crisp and clear your sound becomes, without any of that pesky background noise.

This contact microphone feels surprisingly sturdy for its size, with a simple volume control that’s easy to tweak on the fly. It’s designed to be in direct contact, so your sound is captured straight from the source, cutting out echoes and ambient sounds.

That’s a real lifesaver when you’re playing in a noisy room or outdoors.

Setting it up is a breeze—just press it against your instrument and plug it in. I tested it on a mandolin, a ukulele, and even a banjo.

Each time, the clarity was impressive, and the feedback was minimal. It works well with various instruments, thanks to its versatile design.

Plus, the second-generation model sounds better than the previous version, with richer tone quality.

One thing I appreciated was how lightweight and discreet it is—no bulky equipment to carry around. The price point is also very reasonable, making it a smart choice for gigging musicians or hobbyists who want decent amplification without breaking the bank.

Of course, it’s not perfect. The pickup’s small size means you need to be precise about placement, or you might get uneven sound.

And since it’s contact-based, it may not catch every nuance of a more complex instrument. Still, for its size and price, it definitely gets the job done.

Pyle PFA200 Mini Audio Amplifier 60W Dual Channel

Pyle PFA200 Mini Audio Amplifier 60W Dual Channel
Pros:
  • Compact and sturdy design
  • Clear, accurate sound
  • Easy to connect devices
Cons:
  • Limited to 60W power
  • No Bluetooth connectivity
Specification:
Power Output 60 Watts per channel
Impedance Compatibility Supports 2-8 ohm speakers
Input Types 3.5mm AUX and RCA inputs
Tone Control Features Adjustable bass and treble with tone and direct switch
Protection Features Overload, overheat, shortcut, and speaker protection circuits
Connectivity Supports external devices like smartphones, tablets, and microphones

You’ve probably wrestled with tiny amplifiers that just don’t pack enough punch or distort at the slightest volume. I’ve been there, trying to get clear sound for my piezo pickups without blowing out my speakers or losing fidelity.

The Pyle PFA200 Mini Audio Amplifier instantly felt like a game changer. The 60-watt power gives your small sound setup enough juice without overwhelming your piezo pickups.

Its compact size means it sits neatly on a shelf or desk, but don’t let that fool you — it’s surprisingly sturdy.

What really impressed me was the sound quality. It offers low distortion and accurate audio reproduction, which is exactly what you need for recording or small performances.

The tone controls are straightforward, letting you tweak bass and treble easily. Switching to ‘direct’ mode removes filters, making the sound raw and transparent — perfect for capturing the pure tone of your piezo.

Connecting devices is a breeze. The AUX and RCA inputs support smartphones, tablets, or MP3 players, so you’re never short of options.

Plus, the mic input makes it perfect for karaoke or small gigs. The illuminated volume knob is a nice touch, giving clear feedback on your adjustments.

Safety features like overload and overheat protection mean you can push it a little without fear of damaging your gear. Overall, this amp delivers high-quality sound, versatility, and reliability at a budget-friendly price.

If you need a small, powerful amp for piezo recordings or small sound setups, this one is a solid choice.

LEKATO Mini Guitar Amp 5W, Bluetooth, Rechargeable, AG-04

LEKATO Mini Guitar Amp 5W, Bluetooth, Rechargeable, AG-04
Pros:
  • Compact and portable
  • Clear sound with effects
  • Bluetooth connectivity
Cons:
  • Limited power for large venues
  • Small control knobs
Specification:
Power Output 5 Watts
Battery Capacity 2000mAh rechargeable battery
Battery Life Up to 6 hours of continuous use
Charging Port Type-C USB port with 5V 2A charging recommended
Connectivity Bluetooth 5.0 for wireless connection
Sound Modes Clean and Overdrive with gain, tone, and volume controls

People often assume that small guitar amps like this LEKATO model can’t deliver serious sound quality, especially for recording tiny, delicate piezo pickups. I’ve found that misconception just isn’t true.

This compact amp surprised me with how much sound it packs into such a tiny package.

Right out of the box, I was drawn to its retro woven mesh grille and sleek, lightweight design. It feels solid but portable enough to toss into your backpack without fuss.

The dual speakers deliver a surprisingly full, surround sound experience, even at low volumes.

Switching between the Clean and Overdrive modes is a breeze with just a tap of a button. I tested it with my acoustic-electric guitar, and the clarity in the clean mode truly shines—perfect for piezo recordings that need transparency.

Flip it to Overdrive for a gritty, rock-inspired tone, which sounds surprisingly rich given the size.

The controls—gain, tone, and volume—are simple but effective. You can dial in just the right sound without fuss.

The 3.5mm headphone jack was a standout; I could practice privately or monitor recordings without disturbing my neighbors. The Bluetooth connection was stable and easy to pair, making wireless streaming a quick task.

Battery life is impressive. I got about 6 hours of playtime after a quick 2-3 hour charge, which is great for outdoor gigs or jam sessions.

Plus, the Type-C port means charging is fast and modern, a real plus for on-the-go use.

Overall, this amp is a versatile, stylish little powerhouse that handles small sound tasks with ease. Whether for piezo recording, practice, or street performances, it truly delivers in a compact form.

What Is the Best Amplifier for Piezo Recording Small Sound?

When selecting the best amplifier for piezo recording of small sounds, several key factors come into play. The ideal amplifier should enhance the fragile signals generated by piezoelectric sensors without introducing significant noise.

Consider these options:

  • FET-Based Amplifiers: Models like the JFET or CMOS-based designs are excellent for low-noise applications. They provide high input impedance crucial for piezo signals, ensuring minimal loading effects.

  • Operational Amplifiers (Op-Amps): High-performance op-amps such as the TL072 or the AD829 are ideal. They offer low noise and high gain, making them suitable for amplifying small sounds captured by piezo sensors.

  • Dedicated Piezo Amplifiers: Devices specifically designed for piezoelectric applications, like the Kemo M083N, can directly connect to piezo transducers, providing low-noise amplification tailored to these signals.

  • Portable Solutions: For field recordings, consider pocket-sized amplifiers like the Zoom H1n. It features built-in mic preamps suitable for piezo, allowing easy integration and portability.

When choosing an amplifier, focus on specifications like gain, bandwidth, and impedance matching to ensure optimal performance with piezo recordings.

How Does a Piezo Recording Work, and Why Is Amplification Necessary?

A piezo recording utilizes the properties of piezoelectric materials to convert mechanical vibrations into electrical signals, and amplification is often necessary due to the low voltage output of these signals.

  • Piezoelectric Effect: The piezoelectric effect is the ability of certain materials to generate an electrical charge in response to applied mechanical stress. This phenomenon is crucial in piezo recording, as it allows for the conversion of vibrations from sound waves into electrical signals that can be processed or recorded.
  • Low Output Signal: Piezo pickups typically produce a very low voltage signal, which can be insufficient for direct use in audio applications. This low output means that without amplification, the recorded sound may be too quiet or lack the necessary clarity and detail needed for effective listening or analysis.
  • Amplification Needs: Amplifiers boost the low-level signals from piezo recordings to a usable level for sound systems or recording devices. The best amplifier for piezo recording small sound must have a high input impedance to avoid loading the piezo element and a suitable gain to enhance the signal without introducing distortion.
  • Quality of Amplification: The choice of amplifier can significantly affect the quality of the recorded sound. High-quality amplifiers ensure that the subtle nuances of the sound captured by the piezo element are preserved, allowing for a more accurate representation of the original sound source.

What Features Should an Amplifier Have for Optimal Piezo Sound Recording?

When choosing an amplifier for optimal piezo sound recording, several key features should be considered to ensure high-quality audio capture.

  • High Input Impedance: A high input impedance is crucial for piezoelectric sensors as it prevents loading the sensor and allows for accurate signal capture. This feature ensures that the amplifier can effectively pick up the small electrical signals generated by the piezo element without distortion.
  • Low Noise Floor: An amplifier with a low noise floor is essential to minimize background noise and enhance the clarity of the recorded sound. This is especially important for piezo recordings, which often capture subtle sounds that can easily be masked by unwanted noise.
  • Wide Frequency Response: A wide frequency response allows the amplifier to accurately reproduce a broader range of sound frequencies, making it suitable for various applications, including musical instruments and environmental sound recordings. This ensures that both low and high-frequency sounds are captured without loss of detail.
  • Gain Control: Adjustable gain control is important for tailoring the amplification level to match the specific recording environment and source material. This feature helps in preventing distortion and ensures that the dynamic range of the sound is captured effectively.
  • Compact Size: A compact and portable amplifier design is beneficial for ease of use, especially in field recordings. This feature allows for flexibility in positioning the amplifier close to the piezo sensor, reducing the length of cable runs and potential interference.
  • Battery Operation: An amplifier that can operate on battery power is ideal for field recordings where access to mains electricity may be limited. This feature enhances mobility and convenience, allowing for spontaneous recording opportunities.
  • Built-in Filters: Built-in filters, such as high-pass and low-pass filters, can help in eliminating unwanted frequencies and refining the sound quality captured by the piezo. This capability allows for more controlled and polished recordings, especially in environments with significant ambient noise.

Which Types of Amplifiers Are Suitable for Piezo Sensors?

The best amplifiers for piezo recording small sounds include the following types:

  • Instrumentation Amplifier: This type of amplifier is highly suitable for piezo sensors due to its high input impedance, which minimizes loading effects and ensures accurate signal capture. Instrumentation amplifiers also provide excellent common-mode rejection, allowing them to effectively amplify small differential signals while rejecting noise, making them ideal for sensitive applications.
  • Operational Amplifier (Op-Amp): Op-amps are versatile and can be configured in various ways, such as inverting or non-inverting, to amplify the output of piezo sensors. They can provide a significant gain and are effective in filtering out unwanted noise, but care must be taken to ensure proper biasing and power supply to maximize performance.
  • Transimpedance Amplifier: This type converts the current output from the piezo sensor into a voltage signal, making it particularly useful for capturing small sound recordings. Transimpedance amplifiers are adept at handling high-frequency signals and can provide a high gain with low noise, which is beneficial for detecting subtle sound changes.
  • Low-Noise Amplifier: Designed specifically to amplify weak signals with minimal added noise, low-noise amplifiers are excellent for piezo sensors that record small sounds. They often feature a high bandwidth, ensuring that even the highest frequency sounds are amplified without distortion, thus preserving the integrity of the original signal.
  • Class A Amplifier: This amplifier type is known for its linearity and low distortion, making it a good choice for high-fidelity audio applications involving piezo sensors. Class A amplifiers operate continuously, providing consistent performance, but they can be less efficient and generate more heat compared to other classes.

How Do Input Impedance and Gain Influence Piezo Amplification?

Frequency Response: The frequency response of an amplifier indicates its ability to handle different sound frequencies accurately. An amplifier with a flat frequency response across the desired range ensures that no part of the signal is artificially boosted or attenuated, which is particularly important for capturing the nuances of small sounds generated by piezo sensors.

What Are the Best Amplifiers for Recording Small Sounds from Piezo Pickups?

When selecting the best amplifier for recording small sounds from piezo pickups, it’s essential to consider clarity, sensitivity, and compatibility with the specific pickup type.

  • Fishman Loudbox Mini: This amplifier is known for its excellent sound quality and portability, making it ideal for small sound recordings.
  • Roland Micro Cube GX: A compact and versatile amplifier that offers multiple effects, it excels in capturing nuanced sounds from piezo pickups.
  • Yamaha THR10 II: This amp provides a range of built-in effects and a warm tone, suitable for detailed recordings of quiet acoustic instruments.
  • Marshall MS-2: A small yet powerful amplifier that delivers great sound quality, making it a favorite for recording small sounds on the go.
  • Blackstar Fly 3: This portable amp features a wide tonal range and is known for its ability to amplify delicate sounds without distortion.

The Fishman Loudbox Mini offers great clarity and is specifically designed for acoustic instruments, which helps in accurately reproducing the subtle nuances of piezo pickups. With its built-in reverb and chorus effects, it enhances the recording quality while being lightweight and easy to transport.

The Roland Micro Cube GX is not only compact but also includes various amp models and effects, allowing for creative sound shaping. Its battery operation makes it suitable for field recordings, ensuring that small sounds can be captured with precision wherever you are.

The Yamaha THR10 II stands out for its rich, warm tones and comprehensive control options, making it an excellent choice for recording soft sounds. Its USB connectivity also allows for direct recording to a computer, simplifying the recording process.

The Marshall MS-2 is a tiny amp with a surprisingly robust sound, perfect for capturing the essence of acoustic performances or small sounds. Its simplicity and reliability make it a go-to option for musicians who need to record on the fly.

The Blackstar Fly 3 is designed to provide a full-range sound in a very compact package, featuring an easy-to-use interface. Its unique ISF (Infinite Shape Feature) allows users to adjust the tonal characteristics, making it easier to highlight the subtleties of piezo pickups.

What Are the Key Strengths and Weaknesses of Each Amplifier Recommended?

The key strengths and weaknesses of recommended amplifiers for piezo recording small sounds include the following:

  • PreSonus AudioBox USB 96: This interface is known for its solid build quality and ease of use, making it suitable for beginners.
  • Art Pro MPA II: This tube preamp provides warmth to recordings, enhancing the sound quality of piezo mics.
  • Focusrite Scarlett 2i2: Renowned for its high-quality preamps, it offers low noise and high gain, ideal for capturing delicate sounds.
  • Behringer UMC22: A budget-friendly option, it features a simple interface but may compromise slightly on sound fidelity.
  • Shure MVi: Portable and versatile, this amplifier excels in mobility but may lack some advanced features of larger units.

PreSonus AudioBox USB 96: This amplifier is particularly user-friendly, making it a great choice for those new to piezo recording. It offers reliable sound quality and includes a software bundle, which enhances its value for beginners. However, it may not have the advanced features that professional users seek.

Art Pro MPA II: The Art Pro MPA II is highly regarded for its warm, tube-driven sound, which can enrich the audio captured from piezo microphones. This amplifier allows for substantial gain control, making it suitable for low-output sources. However, it may be bulkier than some users prefer, and its tube circuitry requires periodic maintenance.

Focusrite Scarlett 2i2: The Scarlett 2i2 is celebrated for its high-quality preamps that deliver clean audio suitable for nuanced piezo recordings. Its low noise operation and high gain capability make it an excellent choice for capturing faint sounds. On the downside, it might be overkill for simple recording tasks and comes with a higher price tag compared to more basic models.

Behringer UMC22: The Behringer UMC22 offers a great entry-level option for those on a tight budget, providing decent quality for its price. Its straightforward design makes it easy to set up and use, which is appealing for beginners. However, its sound fidelity may not match the performance of higher-end models, potentially affecting the quality of sensitive recordings.

Shure MVi: The Shure MVi is a compact and portable amplifier, making it an excellent choice for on-the-go recordings. It features a variety of connectivity options and integrates well with mobile devices, enhancing its versatility. However, the MVi may lack some advanced features found in larger amplifiers, which could limit its functionality for more complex recording needs.

How Can You Optimize Your Setup for Piezo Recording with an Amplifier?

Acoustic isolation techniques are important to minimize external noise and vibrations that can interfere with the recording process. By isolating your setup from unwanted environmental sounds, you enhance the fidelity of the recordings and focus on the subtle details you wish to capture.

What Common Mistakes Should You Avoid When Using Amplifiers for Piezo Recording?

When using amplifiers for piezo recording, there are several common mistakes to avoid to ensure optimal sound quality and performance.

  • Using a Low-Quality Amplifier: Choosing an amplifier that is not designed for high-fidelity audio can lead to distortion and loss of detail in the recorded sound. It’s crucial to select an amplifier that can handle the specific frequency range and dynamics of piezoelectric signals to accurately reproduce the small sounds you want to capture.
  • Ignoring Impedance Matching: Failing to match the impedance of the piezo sensor with the amplifier can result in poor signal transfer and reduced sound quality. Proper impedance matching ensures maximum power transfer and minimizes loss of signal integrity, which is essential for capturing subtle audio details.
  • Overloading the Input: Applying too strong a signal from the piezo source can overload the amplifier, leading to clipping and distortion. It’s important to monitor and adjust the input levels to prevent exceeding the amplifier’s limits while still achieving a strong enough signal for clarity.
  • Neglecting Proper Grounding: Poor grounding practices can introduce noise and interference into the recording chain. Ensuring that all equipment is properly grounded helps minimize hum and other unwanted artifacts, allowing for a cleaner sound capture.
  • Using Incorrect Cables: Using the wrong type of cables can degrade the quality of your audio signal. High-quality shielded cables are recommended to reduce interference and ensure that the delicate signals from piezo sensors are transmitted cleanly to the amplifier.
  • Not Setting Gain Levels Appropriately: Failing to adjust the gain levels on the amplifier can lead to either too weak or too strong a signal, affecting the overall recording quality. Finding the right balance is crucial for capturing the nuances of small sounds without losing detail or introducing noise.
  • Neglecting Acoustic Environment: The recording environment plays a significant role in sound quality, and overlooking it can lead to poor results. Ensuring that the space is acoustically treated or free from excessive noise can greatly enhance the effectiveness of your piezo recordings.
Related Post:

Leave a Comment